Saturday, April 9, 2022

Supreme Court Confirmation Hearings Serve a Purpose

           Republican senators made such a mess at confirmation hearings for Supreme Court nominee Ketanji Brown Jackson that two longtime Court watchers called for eliminating the process altogether for future nominees. Columnists David Lauter and Charles Lane aired their views in their home newspapers, the Los Angeles Times (March 25) and the Washington Post (March 30). Lauter and Lane both worked the Supreme Court beat as reporters for several years before their current roles as columnists.

            History actually proves the value of Supreme Court confirmation hearings, however ugly and uninformative Jackson’s was and others before hers. The first of the nominees to be subjected to a Senate committee hearing was Louis Brandeis, the prominent advocate for consumers’ and workers’ who was nominated in 1916 by President Woodrow Wilson to be the first Jewish justice in the Court’s history. As author Ronald Shafer recalled in a recent retrospective, the practice was ugly from the start.

            Brandeis survived the grilling, which was tinged with overt antisemitism, to win Senate confirmation by a decisive 47-22 vote and to win a reputation as one of the Court’s great justices after serving for twenty-three years until his death in 1939. Through history, many other nominees have survived Senate committee hearings to win confirmation and serve with distinction, including, for example, Hugo Black in 1937 and such more recent justices as Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer in 1993 and 1994 respectively.

            Jackson proved her entitlement to the Supreme Court seat by demonstrating grace, patience, and discretion during more than eighteen hours of grilling by GOP senators who found in her distinguished record points of vulnerability susceptible to partisan attacks. Jackson did so well that she convinced three Republican senators – Romney, Collins, and Murkowski – to break party ranks and to give her a measure of bipartisan support in the eventual 53-47 confirmation vote.

            In fact, no worthy Supreme Court nominee has failed confirmation after a committee hearing and Senate floor vote since the Brandeis precedent a century ago. But confirmation hearings have been instrumental in the Senate’s rejections of four partisan twentieth-century nominees who were rightly denied seats on the nation’s highest court. In the first of those episodes, the Senate rejected President Hoover’s nomination of the federal judge John Parker in 1930 on a 39-41 vote after a Senate hearing exposed Parker’s anti-labor and racist views as elaborated by witnesses from the AFL-CIO and the NAACP.

            In more recent memory, the Senate rejected two of President Nixon’s nominees: Clement Haynsworth and G. Harrold Carswell in 1969 and 1970 respectively after committee hearings exposed their discreditable records as federal judges on race and labor issues and, in Carswell’s case, his mediocre academic and professional qualifications.

            In each of those instances, the Supreme Court and the country emerged as winners as presidents responded by choosing nominees with better judicial temperaments. Hoover responded to Parker’s defeat by nominating Owen Roberts; Nixon chose Warren Burger and Harry Blackmun for the seats that would have gone to Haynsworth and Carswell.

            The modern history of Supreme Court confirmations begins with the Senate’s 58-42 rejection of President Reagan’s nomination of the arch-conservative Robert Bork in 1987. Lost-cause Republicans and conservatives have argued for more than three decades now that Bork was wrongly subjected to partisan attacks and defeated by a mostly partisan vote despite his exemplary academic and professional qualifications.

In fact, six Republicans joined Democrats in rejecting Bork’s nomination by the widest margin in history for an unsuccessful Supreme Court nominee. Bork earned the rejection by testifying in opposition to the constitutional right to privacy and by looking forward to what he called “an intellectual feast” as a Supreme Court justice rather than as a guardian for liberty and justice. With Bork’s defeat, Reagan turned to a well-respected federal judge, Anthony M. Kennedy, who was confirmed in a unanimous Senate vote and served with distinction for three decades despite grumbling from conservatives about his landmark gay rights decisions.

President Obama’s two nominees, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan, underwent partisan grilling by Republican senators in 2009 and 2010 respectively and went on to win confirmation by decisive bipartisan votes: 68-31 for Sotomayor and 63-37 for Kagan. By contrast, President Trump’s three Supreme Court nominees failed to win any significant support from across the political aisle. Three Democrats, wary of impending midterm elections in their home states, voted for Gorsuch in 2017. Kavanaugh got only one Democratic vote in his 52-48 confirmation in 2018; Barrett received no votes from across the political aisle and became the first justice in more than a century to win a Supreme Court seat without a single vote from a senator of the opposing party.

It can also be noted that Clarence Thomas and Brett Kavanaugh masterfully used their hearings to win public and senatorial support in the face of contentious accusations of sexual misconduct before taking the bench. Without the opportunity to address the accusations in person, both of them might have fallen short of confirmation.

Lauter and Lane provide no details on how they expect the confirmation process to be completed without testimony from the nominees themselves. And it seems very unlikely that either the Senate or the American public would be willing to entrust a lifetime Supreme Court seat to a nominee without a close public examination of the nominee’s qualifications and views.

 

Saturday, April 2, 2022

Time for Ethics Reform at Supreme Court

 The disclosures of Ginni Thomas’s active participation in and support for the attempted coup to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election have created an ethics issue for the Supreme Court unique in the Court’s 225-year history. Ginni Thomas has been a prominent conservative activist for years even while her husband has hewed to conservative positions as a justice on the Supreme Court without ever having recused himself from politically charged cases brought by Republican and conservative groups.

Ginni Thomas’s post-election text messages were turned over to the House committee investigating the Jan. 6 assault by Trump’s former chief of staff, Mark Meadows. The New York Times' report on the messages, published on March 24 after earlier disclosures by the Washington Post and CBS News, described Ginni Thomas as having sent Meadows “a barrage of texts imploring him to take steps to overturn the vote.”

In one telling instance, Justice Thomas was the lone dissenter when the Court on Jan. 19 rejected President Trump’s plea to withhold White House records from the House committee. Even though out of office, Trump claimed executive privilege in seeking to withhold the records from the committee.

The Court rejected Trump’s application in Trump v. Thompson to stay the lower court decisions ordering Trump to turn over the records. The unsigned opinion accompanying the order did not elaborate on the reasons for rejecting Trump’s plea. Without writing an opinion, Thomas noted that he would have granted the application.

Two months earlier, Ginni Thomas had signed a letter along with fifty other conservative activists signaling her strong opposition to the work of the Jan. 6 committee. Ginni Thomas has repeatedly insisted that she does not inform her husband of her own political activities. It is not known whether Justice Thomas knew of Ginni’s opposition to the Jan. 6 committee when he considered Trump’s plea to defy the committee’s subpoena for his records pertaining to the Jan. 6 rally and subsequent assault on the Capitol.

Justice Thomas’s failure to recuse himself in the Trump case despite his wife’s publicly reported position has renewed attention to the justices’ exemption from the judicial code of ethics applicable to other federal judges. The code includes a provision requiring recusal under various circumstances, including any interest that the judge’s spouse might have in the proceeding. “A judge shall disqualify himself or herself in a proceeding in which the judge’s impartiality might reasonably be questioned.”

Within the recent past, two Supreme Court spouses in fact changed their professional careers to reduce potential conflicts with their spouses. Martin Ginsburg, a prominent tax lawyer, gave up private practice for a full-time faculty position at Georgetown Law School in 1980 after his wife’s appointment to the D.C. Circuit. Chief Justice Roberts’ wife, Jane Sullivan Roberts, had been a partner at a prominent Washington law firm in the 1990s but moved to a legal recruiting firm after her husband was appointed to the Supreme Court in 2005.

The reform group Fix the Court (FTC) responded to the news of Ginni Thomas’s post-election pleas to the Trump White House with a ten-point agenda to increase the Court’s transparency and accountability. The group’s wish list includes a binding ethics code, formal procedures for requesting recusal, and requirements for justices to disclose their reasons for recusal or for refusing recusal when their impartiality is questioned. The current practice is for justices to provide no explanation for recusal or for declining to recuse.

Fix the Court highlights its central position on its home page: “Supreme Court justices should be bound by the same code of ethics that all other federal judges are required to follow.” The group cites its own research showing that justices over time have been guilty of such ethical lapses as “leaving assets off their annual financial disclosure reports, speaking at partisan fundraisers, and ruling on cases despite credible conflicts of interest.”

The group notes that the justices could “easily and formally adopt the code” on their own “if they so choose.” The group also quotes legal scholars as believing that Congress could “use its statutory authority to compel acceptance of the code.” FTC endorses such an effort.

Fix the Court also urges the Court to ban individual stock ownership by justices and other judges. Roberts and Alito have both recused themselves occasionally from cases involving companies or industries in which they hold investments. The group notes that three justices – Roberts, Breyer, and Alito – own individual shares, according to their financial disclosures, but all three have significantly reduced their holdings since FTC’s founding.

FTC also favors requiring the Judicial Conference to publicly post judges’ speeches and annual financial disclosure reports. The group notes that speeches are posted to some extent but the record is far from complete. The group also credits its own lobbying and pressure from media groups to the new practice since 2017 of digitizing financial disclosure reports to provide easier access to the reports.

The group also urges the Court to continue the current practice of livestreaming oral arguments, a practice the justices adopted after closing the courtroom to the general public in response to the covid19 pandemic. Relatedly, the group also urges that federal courts of appeals be required to livestream audio of their proceedings. Two federal courts of appeals, the D.C. Circuit and the Ninth Circuit in the West, already follow the practice. Based on the importance of the circuit courts’ work and the relative ease of livestreaming, the group contends that immediate audio access should be automatic.

FTC’s agenda is ambitious, but relatively non-controversial and relatively easy to put into effect. With public approval of the Supreme Court falling somewhat according to recent public opinion polls, now would be a very good time to institute some or all of these changes without further delay.

Sunday, March 27, 2022

GOP's "Demagoguery" on Jackson's Record

            When the Senate Judiciary Committee opened the historic hearing on the first-ever black woman nominated for the U.S. Supreme Court [March 21], Republican senators, one after another, all promised respectful consideration of her qualifications. In turn, they appeared to promise to avoid any underhanded partisan attacks of the sort that they attributed to Democrats in blocking Robert Bork’s confirmation to the Supreme Court in 1987 and in trying to derail Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s nomination in 2018.

            Despite relentless criticism from two of the committee’s most partisan Republican members, Missouri’s Josh Hawley and Texas’s Ted Cruz, Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson never flinched and showed “enormous patience” during three days at the witness table, as the National Law Journal’s Marcia Coyle remarked on the PBS NewsHour [March 23].

The committee’s chairman, Illinois’s Dick Durbin, similarly praised Jackson’s temperament as he prepared to wrap up the hearing on Thursday (March 24). “I believe she carried herself with grace and humility,” Durbin remarked.

The centerpiece of the Republicans’ line of attack, indeed virtually the only substantive criticism they could find, was Hawley’s compilation of Jackson’s below-guidelines sentences imposed on defendants in ten child pornography possession cases. The nation’s leading expert on federal sentencing policy, Ohio State University law professor Doug Berman, convincingly refuted the insinuation in a lengthy post on his “Sentencing Law and Policy” blog.

“To be truly fair and sound,” Berman wrote, “any review of Judge Jackson's CP sentencings must include proper context regarding the federal sentencing guidelines for CP which are widely recognized as dysfunctional and unduly severe.”

In fact, according to Berman’s study of the data, Jackson’s sentences were well within “the mainstream” of other federal judges in similar cases. The data from reports by the U.S. Sentencing Commission “document that Judge Jackson's record of imposing below-guideline CP sentences is quite mainstream because: (1) federal judges nationwide typically sentence below the CP guideline in roughly 2 out of 3 cases, and (2) federal judges nationwide, when deciding to go below the CP guideline, typically impose sentences around 54 months below the calculated guideline minimum.”

The Republican line of attack also fell flat with the veteran federal prosecutor, Andrew McCarthy, in an article he wrote for the conservative website National Review online. McCarthy began by stating his opposition to Jackson’s nomination, but went on to describe Hawley’s criticism as “disingenuous.” Hawley’s attack, McCarthy added, “is meritless to the point of demagoguery.”

Republican senators went beyond the cherry-picked compilation of cases to suggest that Jackson was generally “soft on crime” in her sentencing decisions in eight years as a federal district court judge in the District of Columbia (March 2013 – June 2021).

Members of the American Bar Association’s standing committee on the judiciary, appearing before the committee [March 24], testified that they heard no criticism of Jackson’s supposed bias toward defendants in their exhaustive investigation of her record in anonymous interviews with hundreds of lawyers familiar with her work.

“Notably, no judge, defense counsel, or prosecutor expressed any concern in this regard, and they uniformly rejected any accusations of bias,” D. Jean Veta, a senior counsel with the Washington-based law firm Covington & Burling and one of the ABA committee’s lead evaluators, told the senators.

Another of the ABA committee members, Joseph Drayton, a vice president of the National Bar Association, went further by explaining that the committee undertook its own review of Jackson’s sentencing decisions and found no evidence of bias. “We looked the record and how she came out and it didn’t appear as though she favored the prosecutor nor the defense in such cases,” Drayton said.

Despite the convincing refutations, Republicans kept up the line of attack over the weekend [March 26] by recirculating a tweet from no less a legal expert than Donald Trump Jr. “Democrats really doing their best to secure the paedophile [sic] vote for future elections this week,” junior tweeted.

The child pornography line of attack was one of several cynical tactics that Republicans used to score points with their political base rather than to examine Jackson’s qualifications fairly and thoughtfully. Tennessee’s Marsha Blackburn seized on Jackson’s work as federal public defender in representing Guantanamo detainees to suggest that Jackson worked to release “terrorists” from the U.S. prison camp.

Jackson explained, patiently, that she was assigned as federal public defender to represent one of the Guantanamo detainees and continued her representation after his case moved to a private law firm. Blackburn and other Republicans studiously ignored the legal profession’s ethical obligation to provide representation in the U.S. judicial system for anyone accused of criminal conduct. That tradition extends as far back as John Adams’ representation of the British soldiers accused in the so-called Boston massacre.

Cruz also seized on another of the GOP’s favorite issues: critical race theory, by trying to link Jackson, who sits on the board of the private Georgetown Day School, to one of the antiracist titles found in the school’s library. When eventually pressed for a direct answer about her view of CRT, Jackson had a complete answer. “It wouldn't be something that I would rely on if on the Supreme Court,” she stated.

Through three long days at the witness table, Jackson insisted time and time again that she had no ideological agenda and approached cases with detachment and neutrality. Her assurances failed, however, to satisfy the Senate’s Republican leader, Kentucky’s Mitch McConnell, who went to the Senate floor on Friday (March 25) to declare, “I cannot and will not support Judge Jackson for a lifetime appointment to our highest Court.” McConnell’s chief complaint appeared to be Jackson’s refusal to oppose increasing the number of justices on the Court, an issue for Congress to decide, not the Court.

Sunday, March 20, 2022

The Times' Clumsy Blow for Free Speech

         The New York Times struck a clumsy blow for freedom of speech last week [March 18] in an unsigned editorial under the headline, “America Has a Free Speech Problem.” The Times’s editorialists diagnosed the problem as stemming from what they called “a destructive loop of condemnation and recrimination around cancel culture.”
            In a misguided attempt at bothsidesism, the Times faulted “many on the left” for refusing to acknowledge the existence of cancel culture. More substantively, the Times rightly pointed out the hypocrisy of “many on the right” who “for all their braying about cancel culture, have embraced an even more extreme version of censoriousness as a bulwark against a rapidly changing society, with laws that would ban books, stifle teachers, and discourage open discussion in classrooms.”

This recent example illustrates the conservatives’ hypocrisy. The Supreme Court justice Clarence Thomas criticized “cancel culture” in a speech to a Republican audience in Utah on March 12, barely three months after his political activist wife Ginni Thomas joined fifty conservatives in urging the House GOP leader Kevin McCarthy to expel Reps. Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger from the House Republican conference because of their participation in the committee investigating the Jan. 6 insurrection. If McCarthy obliges, that would be cancel culture to the max.

            The Times editorial cited no instance in which a free-speech speaker has been “canceled” by individuals or groups seeking to shun or silence the speaker. The proof of the diagnosis consists, according to the editorial, of the results of a recent poll commissioned by the Times that showed only 34 percent of those surveyed believe that all Americans enjoy freedom of speech completely. Indeed, 84 percent of adult respondents called it a “very serious” or “somewhat serious” problem that some Americans do not speak freely in everyday situations because of fear of retaliation or harsh criticism.

            From this observer’s recollection, the only free-speech speaker to have been effectively canceled during the past few years is Colin Kaepernick, who was blackballed out of his career in professional football based on a backlash by political conservatives. Football fans nationwide, encouraged by Republican politicians and conservatives, objected to Kaepernick’s taking a knee during the playing of the national anthem before an exhibition game in San Diego on Sept. 1, 2016, as a symbolic protest against police brutality against black Americans..

            A Wikipedia entry on “cancel culture” notes that “some public figures claim to have been ‘cancelled’ while continuing their careers as before.” The heavily annotated entry also cites several public opinion polls that record public concern about the issue, including one conducted by the Pew Research Center in 2020.

            The polls simply record the conservatives’ success in coining a weaponized term that necessarily stings and sticks in the public consciousness. A neutral term for the practice could be, for example, “consequence culture” or “call-out culture.” Either of those terms would show the practice to be fully consistent with freedom of speech: the freedom, that is to say, to disagree with what some free-speech speaker says.

            In that regard, it is worth recalling George Orwell’s prescient essay, “Politics and the English Language” (1946), in which he warned that thought corrupts language and language corrupts thought.

            The Times premised its critique on a free speech principle unfound in law books or First Amendment treatises. “Americans are losing hold of a fundamental right as citizens of a free country: the right to speak their minds and voice their opinions in public without fear of being shamed or shunned,” the newspaper lamented.

“This social silencing, this depluralizing of America, has been evident for years, but dealing with it stirs yet more fear,” the newspaper added. “It feels like a third rail, dangerous. For a strong nation and open society, that is dangerous.”

Calling out offensive or hateful speech is an important First Amendment exercise that empowers the marginalized victims of prejudice or discrimination vis-à-vis established opinion leaders with regular platforms like the Times or respected professionals regularly invited to speak at prominent public fora, such as colleges and universities.

To be clear, the powers that be “canceled” black Americans in much of the country for a full century after the end of the Civil War. And LGBT individuals were similarly canceled out of public consciousness through most of U.S. history until the Stonewall protest in New York City in 1969. Only now have black Americans and LGBT Americans summoned the resolve to speak out against those who have silenced them and erased them from the United States’ melting pot.

            The “braying” from conservatives about cancel culture betrays their true purpose: to silence or disarm their opponents, not to establish some principled ground rules for public discourse and debate. The Times deserves a big raspberry for giving aid and comfort to the partisans who claim allegiance to free speech even while enlisting friendly politicians such as Florida’s governor, Ron DeSantis, to suppress free speech in schools and in the public square. [825]

Saturday, March 12, 2022

Thomas's 'Unseemly' Behavior as High Court Justice

                 Clarence Thomas, Supreme Court justice, and his full-time political activist wife Virginia Thomas are Washington’s power couple du jour.  The New York Times lifted them to full-fledged celebrity status by using a flattering photograph of the couple as the cover of the Sunday magazine last month [Feb. 22] under the headline, “The Long Crusade of Clarence and Ginni Thomas.”

The cover photo illustrates the wisdom of Ronald Reagan’s communications team that a journalist’s hard-hitting report matters not a bit if the accompanying visuals are favorable. The Sunday magazine cover with the accompanying headline depicts the long-married couple as dedicated crusaders for political and legal justice.

            Moving away from the photograph, however, readers found a thoroughly documented article by investigative reporters Danny Hakim and Jo Becker that raised several ethical issues about the justice’s participation in political events and about the effect of Ginni’s political work on Thomas’s votes in Supreme Court cases.

            As the most concrete example, Hakim and Becker uncovered Ginni Thomas’s role as a leader of the conservative National Policy Council in encouraging members after the November election to contact legislators in three Biden-carried states to nullify Biden’s popular vote victories in those states. “The aim,” as Hakim and Becker wrote, “was audacious: Keep President Donald J. Trump in power.”
            It needs to be recalled that Trump, throughout this period, was challenging the Supreme Court to show resolve by validating his unsubstantiated claims of voting fraud in the election and by supporting his efforts to overturn the results of the election. In effect, Trump was counting on Justice Thomas and the other Republican-appointed justices as his hole card to support the first ever coup in U.S. history even as Thomas’s wife was encouraging her right-wing allies to do the same.

            Later, Ginni Thomas signed, along with 40 other self-identified conservatives, a Dec. 15 letter calling for the House Republican caucus to expel the two GOP members serving on the select committee investigating the Jan. 6 insurrection at the Capitol. On the very day of the Jan. 6 insurrection, Ginni Thomas in fact urged her Facebook followers to watch how the day unfolded, according to Hakim’s and Becker’s reporting. “LOVE MAGA people!!!!” she posted before the march turned violent. “GOD BLESS EACH OF YOU STANDING UP or PRAYING!”

            As one suggestion of Ginni’s influence on her husband, the reporters noted that Justice Thomas was the lone dissenter from the Court’s 8-1 decision to order the Trump White House to turn over records and correspondence that the House committee was seeking to investigate Trump’s role in the insurrection. Significantly, Thomas participated in the case without recusal, as might have been expected given his wife’s public criticism of the committee’s work.

            Supreme Court experts can recall no Supreme Court spouse in history to have engaged so actively in partisan politics while her husband served on the Court. “I’m sure there are justices’ spouses who have had strong opinions about politics,” Orin Kerr, a law professor at the University of California-Berkeley, told the Times reporters. “What’s unusual here is that Justice Thomas’s wife is an activist in politics. Historically, this is the first example of something like this that I can think of at the Supreme Court.”

            Two weeks after the Times magazine piece, another reporter raised a separate ethical issue about Thomas, this one focused solely on the justice himself and his decision in December to hire the prominent right-wing judicial lobbyist Leonard Leo to promote a new ebook edition of Thomas’s memoir. The article by reporter Roger Sollenberger appeared in the online publication The Daily Beast on March 8 under this headline: “Clarence Thomas’s Strange Pick to Promote His Book Says It All.”

            Sollenberger noted Leo’s history as the former head of the Federalist Society and a “top fundraiser for right-wing judiciary activist groups” and depicted the role of Leo’s public relations firm CRC Advisors as going beyond promoting Thomas’s book and also to promoting a Thomas documentary and serving as registered agent for four Thomas-centric web domains.

            “What makes Thomas’ decision notable is that Leo happens to have a vested interest in the Supreme Court, and his dark money network actively tries to influence rulings,” Sollenberger wrote. Sollenberger quoted several experts as suggesting that Thomas’s connection with Leo “raises further questions about the arch-conservative justice’s deep and shady ties to a sprawling network of dark money organizations and right-wing activist groups, many of which have business before him.”

            Paul Collins, professor of political science at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst and author of several books about the high court told Sollenberger that Thomas’ specific choice of Leo’s firm was “strange” and “unnecessary.” Somewhat less critically, Stephen Gillers, a legal ethics expert at New York University Law School, told Sollenberger that Thomas’s ongoing connection with Leo was newsworthy but not of itself unethical. “It may appear to many people as unseemly,” Gillers said, “but that’s not a legal question.”

Senator Sheldon Whitehouse, a Rhode Island Democrat and longtime Senate critic of the right-wing campaign to control the Supreme Court and the federal judiciary, sharply criticized Thomas’s connection with Leo. “Leo and his CRC Advisors form the head of a many-legged dark-money operation designed to deliver on the priorities of right-wing donor interests,” Whitehouse told Sollenberger.

It is worth recalling here that Republicans hounded Justice Abe Fortas off the Supreme Court in 1969 based on an ethical issue far narrower than those being raised about Thomas’s political involvement today. Fortas was paid $15,000 for teaching a course at American University Law School that was funded by former clients from his law practice. He also accepted a $20,000 speaking fee from a family foundation of the financier Louis Wolfson, then under investigation for securities fraud. Fortas eventually returned the money but his reputation was ruined, leading to the first ever ethics-inspired resignation from the Court.

The Constitution specifies that Supreme Court justices and federal judges serve not for fixed terms but “during good behavior.” A question today for Justice Thomas is how much “unseemly” behavior is needed to disqualify him from continuing to serve on the Court.