Sunday, July 5, 2020

Conservative Anger With Roberts Misreads His Record

      Republican politicians and conservative Supreme Court watchers are angry, angry, angry with Chief Justice Roberts because of his votes in four of the term’s fifty-three decisions so far. Those four votes in divided cases left conservatives with egg on their faces for their political agenda on such culture war issues as abortion, gay rights, gun laws, and immigration. 
      A more complete examination of Roberts’ votes, however, shows that he has been a reliable conservative vote in decisions that divide along the usual conservative-liberal lines. He has toed the conservative line in criminal law and civil litigation issues and in two decisions that rejected efforts by Democrats and progressive groups to ease absentee ballot voting in Wisconsin and Alabama during the current coronavirus pandemic.
      Among twelve 5-4 decisions this term, Roberts has been in the majority in every one. He  gave the liberal bloc a critical fifth vote in only two: the decision to strike down a Louisiana abortion law and the decision to block the Trump administration from rescinding the DACA program protecting undocumented immigrants brought to the United States as children.
      Roberts provided the sixth vote in the decision that extended the federal civil rights law known as Title VII to prohibit discrimination in the workplace on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. Roberts was also part of a six-justice majority in the New York City gun rights case that ended with a nothing-burger after the city repealed the challenged handgun transportation ordinance.
      The armchair psychologists on the right think they know why Roberts strays from conservative dogma. Most commonly, Roberts is viewed as concerned with protecting the Court’s institutional integrity in this hyperpartisan political era. Harvard law professor Richard Lazarus, a friend of Roberts from law school days, views Roberts as trying to send a message to the political branches. “You cannot expect us to behave like partisan legislators,” Lazarus surmises as Roberts’ message, as quoted by the New York Times’ Supreme Court correspondent, Adam Liptak.
      Arkansas’ firebrand Republican senator, Tom Cotton, was among the GOP politicians who denounced Roberts for playing politics with his vote in the Louisiana abortion case. “The chief justice may believe that he’s protecting the institutional integrity of the court,” Cotton remarked to Liptak, “but in reality his politicized decision-making only undermines it.”
      Liptak also describes unnamed conservatives as believing that Roberts’ votes against the administration are motivated by a personal distaste for Trump. These arm-chair psychologists apparently have forgotten that Roberts cast a decisive vote in Trump’s first year in office to uphold Trump’s “Muslim travel ban” despite the distasteful religious and ethnic bias in Trump’s campaign and post-election explanations for the policy. Other critics view Roberts as playing to predominantly liberal editorial pages and the generally liberal slant in legal academia.
      In the current term, Roberts did an enormous favor for Trump in his unilateral order on May 8 to stay the D.C. Circuit’s order granting the House Judiciary Committee access to redacted portions of the Mueller report. Now, surely with Roberts’ support, the Court is letting Trump run out the clock even further by deciding to review the D.C. Circuit’s decision sometime next term, with no decision possible before the November election.
      The conservative grievances with Roberts are so strong that Matt Schlapp of the American Conservative Union is even invoking the “I” word. “If it were up to me, I’d start impeachment proceedings,” Schlapp remarked on Fox News as quoted in a Washington Post account. “If he’s not going to be impeached, he ought to resign and run for Congress.”
      Curt Levey, president of the conservative Committee for Justice, worries just as darkly in an op-ed in the Post [July 2] that Roberts is “following in the disappointingly centrist footsteps of previous swing justice Anthony M. Kennedy.” Levey concedes that a conservative jurisprudence may not always yield conservative results, but he goes on to accuse Roberts of being “guided by ideological or political objectives.”
      In fact, Roberts’ votes in the four cases that upset conservatives this term reflect conservative principles straight out of the judicial restraint textbook. In the abortion case, June Medical Services v. Russo, Roberts followed precedent in providing the fifth vote needed to strike down a Louisiana law virtually identical to a Texas law struck down four years earlier. In the immigration case, Roberts led the 5-4 majority in Regents v. Department of Homeland Security in holding, in effect, that the president cannot abolish a government program based solely on disagreement with the policy or his unsupported view of its supposed illegality.
      Roberts followed “plain meaning” principles of statutory construction in the Title VII case, Bostock v. Clayton County, by concluding that a law prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex necessarily encompasses discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity as well. As for the New York City gun law case, the dispute was clearly moot after the city repealed the ordinance. Roberts’ vote reflected his aversion to judicial activism as seen in his frequent phrasing: “If it’s not necessary to decide a question, it is necessary not to decide it.”
      Roberts need have no fears of impeachment. With lifetime tenure, he can survive the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune from the political right. But the conservative critics who accuse him of playing politics betray themselves by viewing the Court’s decisions solely through their narrow political lenses.

Sunday, June 28, 2020

In Asylum Case, Justices Close Courthouse Doors

      Tens of thousands of Sri Lanka’s minority population Tamils have died in three decades of ethnic and religious conflict in the south Asian island nation formerly known as Ceylon. Despite a ten-year truce in fighting, the Hindu Tamil minority still today faces the threat of what human rights groups regard as genocide at the hands of the Sri Lankan military as directed by the Buddhist Sinhalese majority government.
       Vijayakumar Thuraissigiam, an ethnic Tamil, fears that he could be another victim if returned to his country after a thus-far unsuccessful attempt to obtain asylum in the United States. Thuraissigiam fled Sri Lanka in 2016 after having been abducted and beaten by unidentified assailants. He then found his way to Mexico, crossed into southern California on January 17, 2017, and has been detained in an immigration facility ever since his arrest by a Border Patrol agent just twenty-five yards north of the border.
      Thuraissigiam applied for asylum but, unable to identify his assailants or their motivation, he failed to satisfy two executive branch officials that he had “a credible fear of persecution” if he were returned to his native country. In a courthouse-closing decision last week [June 25], the Supreme Court prevented Thuraissigiam from making his case to an independent federal judge despite two recent precedents allowing noncitizens to use federal habeas corpus to try to gain their freedom.
      The Supreme Court’s decision in Department of Homeland Security v. Thuraissigiam [June 25] upheld provisions in a 1996 immigration law that limit most asylum applicants in their ability to use habeas corpus to obtain judicial review of their asylum claims. Thuraissigiam, represented by attorneys from the American Civil Liberties Union, argued that those restrictions amounted to an unconstitutional suspension of habeas corpus and a due process violation.
      Writing for the Court’s conservative majority, Justice Samuel Alito adopted a dewy-eyed view of the procedural protections for asylum applicants after citing the current backlog of more than 1 million pending cases. Over the past five years, fewer than one-fourth of the applicants have been screened out at the initial interview, according to statistics found by the Government Accountability Office (GAO). Many applicants later drop their claims, and the vast majority of those that survive an initial screening are found to be “meritless,” according to Alito.
      Alito notes that the asylum applicant has two more levels of review after the asylum officer’s initial interview before a supervisor and an immigration judge. Significantly, the immigration judge is actually an executive branch official despite the title. Alito is no fan of government bureaucrats in other contexts, but he expresses confidence that this three-level system of review is sufficient for the purpose without allowing the asylum applicant their day in an actual court of law.
      In a brief filed with the Supreme Court supporting Thuraissigiam’s plea, several asylum law professors instead view Thuraissigiam’s case as “a paradigmatic example” of the need for review by an Article III court. “Bona fide asylum seekers are routinely removed despite having strong claims to protection,” Washington, D.C., attorney Roy Englert wrote in the brief filed on behalf of the professors: Harvard’s Deborah Anker and Sabrineh Andalar, the University of Texas’s Denise Gelman, and the University of California-Hastings’ Karen Musalo.
      Quite simply, according to the professors, asylum officers “fail to provide asylum seekers with sufficient opportunity to show credible fear.” The would-be refugee, unfamiliar with U.S. law and unrepresented by attorney, has multiple disadvantages, according to the professors, in trying to make their case to overworked asylum officers at the border.
      Among several factors, the professors cite reticence, trauma, and language barriers. The would-be refugee may be less than forthcoming because of an internalized habit of secrecy and distrust of authorities from their experiences in their home country. They may also be “reluctant to share the details of their traumatic circumstances,” according to the professors. Language barriers add to the applicant’s difficulty in making their case even if a translator is provided, as required by regulation. The translator may also render the applicant’s story imprecisely based on poor understanding of colloquialisms and idioms in the applicant’s home country.
      These difficulties require the asylum officer, according to the professors, to go beyond the rote recitation of questions in an interview form and to probe deeply into the applicant’s account. “[T]he asylum officer must probe and ask follow-up questions that are informed not only by the asylum seeker’s statements but also by information relating to the country from which the asylum seeker has fled,” Englert writes in summarizing the professors’ views.
      In a densely historical opinion, Alito dismisses as irrelevant Supreme Court decisions from the 19th century on that allowed noncitizens to get their cases into courts of law, including the quite recent decision in Boumediene v. Bush (2008) permitting Guantanamo detainees to use habeas corpus to challenge their imprisonment.
      Sotomayor is persuasive in depicting the new decision as inconsistent with precedent and the historic purpose of habeas corpus as a safeguard of individual liberty. “The majority,” she writes in a critical summary, “declares that the Executive Branch’s denial of asylum claims in expedited removal proceedings shall be functionally unreviewable through the writ of habeas corpus, no matter whether the denial is arbitrary or irrational or contrary to governing law.” So much for the huddled masses yearning to breathe free.

Sunday, June 21, 2020

Supreme Court Teaches Trump a Lesson

      Midway through the third year of his presidency, Donald Trump extravagantly declared that the Constitution’s Article II gives him “the right to do whatever I want as president.” The Supreme Court reminded him once again last week [June 18] that the court can set limits on his power even as the justices are weighing whether to enforce subpoenas by investigative bodies looking into Trump’s personal finances.
      The Court ruled, narrowly but decisively, that Trump’s Cabinet secretaries cannot eliminate the Obama administration’s soft-on-immigration policy known as DACA just because the president wants it done and just because the president stirs up anti-immigrant feelings to appeal to his political base. The policy gives an estimated 700,000 so-called Dreamers — immigrants brought to the United States as children — protection against deportation as well as authorization for legal employment in the United States, the only country most have ever known.
      Writing for a five-vote majority in Department of Homeland Security v. Regents of University of California, Chief Justice John G. Roberts in effect told the administration that it can rescind the prior policy only by following procedures established by law. For the second year in a row, Roberts gave Trump a remedial lesson in constitutional law just as the Supreme Court was nearing the end of a politically charged term.
      One year ago, Roberts was also the author and the pivotal vote in another closely divided decision, Department of Commerce v. New York, that blocked Trump’s lapdog secretary of Commerce, Wilbur Ross, from adding a citizenship question at the president’s order. In that case, as in the DACA case, Roberts acknowledged the president’s authority to make the policy decision at issue but insisted, as a rule-of-law technician, that the executive branch has to follow the law, not the president’s partisan views or whims.
      A year ago, Roberts cast the decisive vote in the census case after finding the Commerce Department’s rationales for adding a citizenship question to be “pretextual.” In the DACA case, Roberts also faulted the Homeland Security secretaries’ efforts to justify the policy decision — in particular, Kirstjen Nielsen’s memorandum purporting to add new rationales to her predecessor’s earlier decision to rescind the policy. “This is not the case for cutting corners to allow DHS to rely upon reasons absent from its original decision,” Roberts wrote.
      Predictably, Trump and many of the conservative Court watchers chimed in quickly to criticize the Court generally and two of the justices personally: Roberts and Trump’s own appointee, Neil Gorsuch, who authored the 6-3 decision earlier in the week [June 15] to extend the federal job discrimination law to gay and transgender employees.
      Trump’s tweet after the DACA decision attacked both of the defeats in effect as betrayals of the conservatives and Republicans who worked so hard to remake the Court in Trump’s own image with Gorsuch and his second appointee, Brett Kavanaugh. “These horrible and politically charged decisions coming out of the Supreme Court are shotgun blasts into the face of people who are proud to call themselves Republicans or conservatives,” Trump tweeted.
      The conservative TV talk show host Mark Levin was particularly incensed after Gorsuch wrote and Roberts joined the decision in the LGBT rights case, Bostock v. Clayton County. Levin called the ruling an example of  “complete disregard for the law” and “legislative activism in violation of separation of powers.” He went on: “Roberts no longer pretends to be a judge; now Gorsuch has left his robe behind as well (and it’s not the first time).
      Roberts joined Gorsuch’s opinion without writing separately, but both of the justices had signaled during oral arguments that they were likely to find that Title VII’s prohibition against discrimination “because of sex” necessarily applies, because of plain text meaning, to discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. “An employer who fires an individual for being homosexual or transgender fires that person for traits or actions it would not have questioned in members of a different sex,” Gorsuch wrote in the money quote in the decision. “Sex plays a necessary and undisguisable role in the decision, exactly what Title VII forbids.”
      Trump appeared to be unfazed by Monday’s decision once he reacted after maintaining Twitter silence for several hours. “They’ve ruled, and we live with the decision,” he told reporters. By contrast, Trump vowed promptly after the DACA decision that the administration would take the Court’s cue to try again to eliminate the policy.
      For a nation beset by a deadly pandemic and a deep recession, the Court’s decisions provided a measure of consolation that the rule of law still holds in this constitutional republic, however ill-informed the president may be. “The central message” of the rulings, Harvard law professor Richard Lazarus told NPR’s Nina Totenberg, “is the law applies to everybody, and that includes the President of the United States."
      Lazarus may have spoken too soon, however. The Court is still weighing two important cases testing whether Trump can block subpoenas about his finances issued by two House committees and by the New York City district attorney’s office. Those two cases — Trump v. Mazars USA and Trump v Vance — were argued on May 12 and are due to be decided by the end of the month.