Sunday, June 14, 2020

In Flynn Case, Independent Judge Draws a Line

      In the movie Judgment at Nuremberg, the once respected German jurist Ernst Janning, played by Burt Lancaster, tries to explain away his part in Adolf Hitler’s corruption of the German judiciary. With the trial over, Janning tells the American judge who presided over his conviction, “I never knew it would come to that.”
      Playing the part of the wise American judge Dan Haywood, Spencer Tracy has no sympathy. “Herr Janning,” Tracy responds, “it came to that the first time you sentenced a man to death you knew to be innocent.”
      In Donald Trump’s America, the so-called Department of Justice is seeking to corrupt the federal judiciary not by sending an innocent person to the death chamber but by asking a federal court to let Trump’s former national security adviser Michael Flynn go free after pleading guilty in December 2017 to the crime of lying to federal law enforcement investigators.
      By fortunate coincidence, the Justice Department’s unprecedented plea to dismiss charges against a guilty-pleading defendant was filed before a federal judge, Emmet Sullivan, who — according to a photo caption in The New York Times —  “is known for holding prosecutors to account.” The Times’ profile opened by recalling Sullivan’s actions in 2008 in appointing a special prosecutor to investigate government misconduct in prosecuting the powerful Alaska senator, Ted Stevens, on corruption charges.
      In Flynn’s case, the Trump Justice Department is taking a different tack by admitting supposed wrongdoing after Trump and Attorney General William Barr both publicly questioned the prosecution. Trump and Barr both contend that the Obama administration FBI undertook the investigation on flimsy grounds and in effect tricked the retired three-star general into lying to the feds on matters immaterial to any legitimate criminal case.
      Barr commissioned a review of the case by a former U.S. prosecutor with the clear expectation that the ex-prosecutor, John Dunham, was to lay out grounds for letting Flynn walk. Dunham, a Republican, did what was expected and his report became the basis for the government’s motion to dismiss all charges against Flynn.
      After receiving the government’s unopposed motion to dismiss the prosecution, Sullivan, now in his twenty-sixth year on the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, determined that he needed independent advice on how to rule. Sullivan appointed a retired federal judge from New York, John Gleeson, as “amicus” to marshal any legal arguments against granting the motion.
      Gleeson, known like Sullivan for his independence, concluded in a 73-page brief filed on Wednesday [June 10] that the government’s move to dismiss charges against Flynn was “politically motivated” and amounted to “gross prosecutorial abuse.” Gleeson shredded the government’s conclusions about purported misconduct in the prosecution and found them instead to be “obviously pretextual.”
       “The reasons offered by the government are so irregular, and so obviously pretextual, that they are deficient,” Gleeson wrote. The rationales, the former judge continued, “reveal an unconvincing effort to disguise a decision to dismiss that is based solely on the fact that Flynn is a political ally of President Trump.”
      The administration filed its motion in the Flynn case on May 7 under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 48, which allows the government to dismiss a prosecution “with the leave of the court.” In this case, however, the government is arguing that a court has no discretion: no authority whatsoever to grant the motion with the government and the defendant in accord.
      Attorneys for Flynn and the administration argued that position in a 90-minute session last week [June 12] before a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. The lawyers were asking the appeals court to issue an order — in legal parlance, a “writ of mandamus” — to direct Sullivan to grant the government’s motion without any further review or in-court proceedings.
      With two Republican appointees and one Democratic appointee on the randomly selected panel, judicial handicappers might have been forgiven for expecting the Trump administration to get its way in the case. But instead, Judge Karen Henderson, a veteran jurist appointed to the D.C. Circuit by President George W. Bush, appeared to agree with her Obama-appointed colleague, Robert Wilkins, that Sullivan should be allowed to rule in the Flynn case without interference at this stage.
      Henderson described Sullivan as “an old hand” and “an excellent judge.” Maybe Sullivan appointed “an intemperate amicus,” Henderson suggested, “but that doesn’t mean he’s going to deny the motion.” Instead, she and Wilkins both appeared ready to allow Sullivan to hold the hearing on the motion that he has scheduled a month from now, on July 15. As the junior judge of the panel, Trump appointee Naomi Rao appeared at one point to favor a sort of middle-ground position that would order Sullivan how to proceed without actually ordering him to grant the motion.
      Rao at one point invited the administration’s lawyer, principal deputy solicitor general Jeffrey Wall, to elaborate on the separation-of-powers argument that Sullivan had no authority other than to grant the motion. “It’s not up to courts to probe whether the government has pure or impure motives,” Wall answered.
      Wall noted that Gleeson, in his brief, had made serious charges of misconduct against both Trump and Barr. Given the political environment, he warned that any hearing on the motion “threatens to be a public spectacle” that could tarnish both the judiciary and the executive. In truth, however, Trump and Barr have already tarnished the executive’s standing beyond repair and Sullivan deserves commendation for standing up for the independent judiciary.

Sunday, June 7, 2020

In Trump’s Bluster, Telltale Signs of Weakness

      Better late than never, James Mattis, the retired general who served as President Trump’s first secretary of defense, broke his silence last week [June 3] to denounce what he called Trump’s “deliberate effort” over three years to divide rather than try to unify the American people.
      The final straw that broke Mattis’ loyalty as a military man to the president was Trump’s use of armed soldiers to clear protesters out of Lafayette Square to allow the president a transparently political photo opportunity in front of St. John’s Episcopal Church. Mattis’s successor, Mark Esper, walked alongside Trump for the reality show-type tableau, as did General Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, dressed in combat fatigues.
      Mattis opened his letter, as later published in full in The Washington Post, by recalling his oath to support the Constitution taken 50 years earlier when he joined the military. “Never did I dream,” Mattis wrote, “that troops taking that same oath would be ordered under any circumstances to violate the constitutional rights of their fellow citizens – much less to provide a bizarre photo op for the elected commander-in-chief, with military leadership standing alongside.”
      Trump, spared from military service in the Vietnam era thanks to bone spurs, staged the tableau to refute the unflattering suggestion of cowardice in reports that he had been sheltered from “Black Lives Matters” protesters in the secure White House bunker. Once in front of the historic St. John’s Church, Trump awkwardly held a Bible in his outstretched right arm to demonstrate, one supposes, his Christian piety. But the staging backfired in multiple respects.
      The Rev. Mariann Budde, archbishop of the Episcopal diocese of Washington, took offense that Trump had given no advance of his plan to use the church for his visit. She noted that Trump, of course, would have been welcome to use the church to pray or meet with parishioners, but she berated him for using the unopened Bible as a political prop.
      Trump’s entourage that day also included his lapdog attorney general, William Barr, who had personally inspected the park hours earlier to lay plans for the later dispersal of the peaceful protesters. Barr’s unquestioning obedience to Trump’s wishes earned him a spot as a named defendant in a federal court suit that American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) lawyers filed the next day charging him and other administration officials with violating the protesters’ free-speech rights by ordering the use of gas and rubber bullets to clear them from the park and the adjoining street.
      By week’s end, Bishop Budde had amplified her criticism of Trump with an op-ed in The New York Times [June 6] that described the visit as “outrageous” and cited messages she received from around the country to similar effect. Trump, she explained, “used sacred symbols to cloak himself in the mantle of spiritual authority, while espousing positions antithetical to the Bible that he held in his hands.”
      Mattis’s indignation over Trump’s actions also drew support by week’s end: specifically, from a chorus of 89 former Defense Department officials in a stinging op-ed in The Washington Post. The signers, including four former secretaries of defense, blasted what they called Trump’s “shocking promise to send active-duty members of the U.S. military to ‘dominate’ protesters in cities throughout the country — with or without the consent of local mayors or state governors.”
      Esper also dissociated himself from Trump’s plan to use active-duty troops to try to quiet the protests sweeping cities throughout the country over George Floyd’s death at the hands of Minneapolis police officers. “The option to use active-duty forces in a law enforcement role should only be used as a matter of last resort and only in the most urgent and dire of situations,” Esper said in addressing the issue on Wednesday [June 3]. “We are not in one of those situations now.”
      Trump nevertheless made good on his promise in Washington, D.C., itself by sending troops to stand guard at the Lincoln Memorial and, with Barr’s help, by posting Justice Department personnel in riot-protective gear throughout the city’s streets. The sight of armed troops in the nation’s capital city inevitably brought to mind the images of tanks that the Chinese government deployed in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square three decades ago to quell student demonstrations.
      MSNBC researchers dug up an interview that the mediagenic Donald Trump gave to Playboy at the time praising the Communist regime for showing “strength” in dealing with the demonstrators. For reference, the number killed in Tiananmen Square has been put at 241 and the number of wounded at 7,000. Trump has yet to order tanks to city streets or to issue shoot-to-kill orders, but he is failing badly in his efforts to show strength.
      Instead, Trump is flailing weakly as polls show him 10 percentage points behind his presumptive Democratic opponent, former vice president Joe Biden, five months before the November election. Law-and-order themes may not be enough to save Trump from the harsh reality of having mismanaged the response to the coronavirus pandemic, now with more than 100,000 deaths nationwide and economic pain to a degree unseen since the Depression.
      Biden himself answered Trump’s bluster and stagecraft later that evening with a speech in Philadelphia with different themes. “I promise you this. I won’t traffic in fear and division,” Biden said. “I won’t fan the flames of hate. I will seek to heal the racial wounds that have long plagued this country — not use them for political gain.”

Sunday, May 31, 2020

Dark Money Fuels GOP's Capture of U.S. Courts

      Money has long been recognized as the mother’s milk of electoral politics, in the phrasing of the legendary California politico Jesse Unruh. Now, for at least the past three years, money has also been the mother’s milk of judicial politics in the right-wing’s partial capture of the Supreme Court and the federal judiciary.
      A detailed report by three Democratic senators — New York’s Chuck Schumer, Michigan’s Debbie Stabenow, and Rhode Island’s Sheldon Whitehouse — released last week [May 27] untangles the web of dark money-funded organizations linked to the conservative-libertarian Federalist Society that have helped Republicans confirm two Supreme Court justices and a near record number of life-tenured federal judges during President Trump’s time in office.
      The impact of the mostly secretive spending by far-right legal advocacy groups can be seen most clearly in the undisclosed sources of the six- and seven-figure ad buys by the Judicial Crisis Network (JCN) in regard to the three most recent Supreme Court nominations. JCN, with offices in the same building that houses the Federalist Society, spent $7 million to help bottle up President Obama’s nomination of Judge Merrick Garland to the Supreme Court and then $10 million in support of Trump’s two Supreme Court nominees, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh.
      If the group had spent that money in support of candidates for elected federal office — Congress or the presidency — federal campaign finance law would have required full disclosure of the donors to help the public watch out for undue influence by moneyed interests. Instead, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh took the bench, after historically narrow confirmations in the Republican-majority Senate, without any public accounting of the debts that they may owe to  corporate fat-cats or ax-grinding ideologues of the far right.
      One can be sure, however, based on their public appearances at the Federalist Society’s gala dinners in Washington shortly after their respective confirmations that Gorsuch and Kavanaugh are both fully aware of the gratitude they owe to their friends and supporters from the confirmation fights. When he spoke at the black-tie dinner in November 2018, Gorsuch declared that his confirmation showed that “a committed originalist and textualist” can be confirmed to the Supreme Court — a pledge that brought hearty applause from the committed originalists and textualists in the audience.
      A year later, Kavanaugh, fresh from the painful confirmation fight marked by sharply disputed charges of sexual misconduct from his high school days, appeared at times to be choking up during a speech that he said was built on a single theme: gratitude. “There’s a saying that adversity introduces a man to himself,” he told the black-tie audience at Washington’s Union Station, “it also reveals your true friends.”
      The Democratic senators’ report — titled, “Captured Courts: The GOP’s Big Money Assault On The Constitution, Our Independent Judiciary, And The Rule of Law” — tells at least part of the story about the sources of the Federalist Society’s money: $20.7 million in donations in 2017. A major chunk, $5.5 million, came from a group, Donors Trust, linked to the fiercely right-wing Koch brothers, and another $2.4 million from private foundations or trusts controlled by wealthy families, some with industry ties. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, a frequent amicus in business-related cases at the Supreme Court, chipped in $50,000; and several big corporations added five- or six-figure contributions.
      The Federalist Society disclaims any policy-related advocacy, but it is unsurprising that with funding sources such as these that the society, its speakers, and now its scores of federal judges give scant regard to racial justice, environmental protection, consumer protection, or workers’ rights. In short, the society is a partisan advocacy group, its protestations to the contrary notwithstanding.
       “[D]ark money is a uniquely pernicious threat when deployed to capture the institution in which fairness and equality under the law matters most: our courts,” the Democratic senators state in their report. “When dark money is deployed to capture seats on the federal courts, the effects can last for generations.”
      Indeed, with Gorsuch and Kavanaugh both in their 50s, their confirmations appear all but certain to lock in a conservative, Republican majority on the Supreme Court for another decade unless Justice Clarence Thomas decides, improbably, to retire while in good health. Meanwhile, Trump has been allowing the Federalist Society, and its longtime leader Leonard Leo, to take the lead role in vetting nominees for lower federal courts.
      With seven months remaining in his four-year term, Trump has already installed a near-record 194 judges on federal courts — just below President Jimmy Carter’s record 208 judges at this point in his one-term presidency. Trump’s judges include 51 appointed to the influential federal courts of appeals: nearly one-third of the total number of judges on the intermediate-level circuit courts. The Senate’s Republican leader, Kentucky’s Mitch McConnell, who slowed action on Obama’s judicial nominations in his final year in office, has fast-tracked Trump’s judicial nominations and is vowing now to “leave no vacancy behind” by the end of Trump’s time in office.
      In the Trump era, the blatant politicization of federal judicial appointments, in contrast to the relative bipartisanship through most of U.S. history, may seem the least of his offenses against political and constitutional norms. But the senators conclude by underscoring the long-term threat to democracy. “It is time for America to reckon with the reality that our courts are being captured,” they write. “Nothing less than our democracy is at stake.”